Top 10 Infant Formulas (Oct. 2018) – Reviews and Buyers Guide

Most mothers can feel completely overwhelmed when their little one comes along. I know that I was. It can be so hard to know which advice to turn to when you hear so much different information. Feeding your baby can also seem like an incredibly controversial decision.

Whilst many mothers feel very strongly about breastfeeding, some moms are not able to commit to breastfeeding their child. There can be medical reasons why, but also other, very valid reasons too.

If you have heard bad things about infant formula, these reviews could change your mind. Most experts recommend breast milk for babies, but infant formula can actually contain extra vitamins that breast milk does not provide.

The carefully crafted formulas are created to support the growth of your baby. Additional benefits are eye and brain development, immune strengthening nutrition and great gains in weight, as well as length and head circumference. The infant right formula can really boost your baby’s first year.

And we are not just saying this. As part of our team, we have a dedicated pediatrician to review all information and products. Our pediatrician has ensured that all products provide real benefits for your baby. We have also consulted other doctors for a wide range of expert opinions on each product on our review list.

Remember, every baby is different and your choice should be based on what is best for you and your baby. In these reviews, we have covered many of the pros and cons of both breast and formula feeding. We hope that you will be able to use this information to make the best decision for yourself.

Whatever your reasons, if you want to know which is the best infant formula for your baby, read our top ten review to see where to start.

Why Should You Trust Us?

I know that as a mother, it can seem impossible to know who to trust. Everyone seems to have their own advice, whether it is parents, friends or strangers on the internet. Whenever I put my trust in some advice, I started to doubt whether it was really the best thing for my child.

When it comes to parenting, it can seem like an impossible task to decide which advice is really the best to follow. This can be even more difficult when it comes to feeding your child. This is something that many mothers feel very strongly about and it can be hard to separate fact from fiction. You just want to know which is the best infant formula for your child.

If you have been feeling overwhelmed by all of the information available, let me convince you why our reviews will be both informative and helpful.

We have Experience

For the past five years, the dedicated Supplemania team has been conducting methodical product research. With our combined years of experience in the fields of health and nutrition, you can trust that we know what we are doing.

Not only do we have combined experience in health and nutrition, we also have a dedicated pediatrician to review all of the products and reviews that we received.

Helping You

One of the core Supplemania principles is a commitment to helping you to make an informed decision. Our reviews will help you to understand the real differences between baby formula brands.

Methodical Research

Each product review is the result of over 48 hours of research. We have thoroughly investigated all aspects of each brand.

Unbiased Opinion

I know that when I first started researching the best infant formula, I never knew who to trust. Everyone seemed to have their own agenda. At Supplemania, we have reviewed a variety of infant formula brands so that you know we are unbiased. We will never try to promote one specific brand.

In total, we reviewed over 30 products from different brands. We shortlisted the best 13 products. Finally, we looked at each product closely to determine the top 10 best infant formulas. Our top 10 features multiple brands, each product was judged solely on its own individual merits.

We were also careful to eliminate any bias in our reviewing team. Any subjective reviews were removed from our research. Our research report is also open and available for free for you to review.

Only the Best Formulas

We have selected only infant formulas that are proven so actually support your baby’s overall growth. We have only researched formulas suitable for babies aged newborn up to 12 months. These formulas are carefully made to be the best nutrition for children of that age.

Breastfeeding Vs Formula Feeding:

All About Breastfeeding

Nursing your baby can be a wonderful experience. Breastfeeding is often a precious bonding moment for both mother and baby. In addition, breast milk also provides ideal nourishment for a growing baby.

Many health organizations recommend breastfeeding as the best choice for babies. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) actually recommends exclusively breastfeeding your baby for the first six months. Other organizations agree that breastfeeding should be encouraged for as long as mother and baby are willing.

This opinion is based upon the many benefits that breastfeeding offers.

Fighting Infections

Breastfeeding actually passes antibodies from mother to baby. Breastfed babies often have lower rates of infection than formula-fed infants. Some infections that are prevented by mom’s antibodies include ear infections, diarrhea, and respiratory infections.
Hospitalisation rates are generally lower in breastfed babies. Illnesses such as meningitis, asthma and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) may be prevented through breastfeeding. That is why breastfeeding is particularly beneficial to premature babies with compromised immune systems.

Nutrition and Digestion

Breast milk is often described as the “perfect food” for human babies because of its unique makeup. Breast milk is the ideal blend of lactose, protein, and fat for baby’s diet. Easily digestible and perfectly nutritious, it is easy to see why rates of digestive issues are lower in breastfed babies.

However, despite being a great, natural source of nutrients, breast milk is lacking in vitamin D. Infant formulas contain all vital nutrients, including vitamin D, thanks to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

Free and Convenient

One of the biggest advantages of breast milk is the cost. It is entirely free, produced by your own body. When breastfeeding, you also never need to worry about leaving the bottle at home or a last-minute store run.

Bonding

I mentioned the bonding experience that nursing can provide. Skin-to-skin contact between baby and mom when breastfeeding is one of the most intimate experiences. This can really enhance the natural connection between mother and child.

It’s also Great for Moms

Studies indicate that breastfeeding lowers the risk of cancers, including breast, uterine and ovarian cancer.

Breastfeeding Challenges

Unfortunately, breastfeeding can be a challenge for some mothers and babies. Some moms find that their baby is eager and easy to breastfeed, others can need some time to get used to it.

These challenges are often most common in the first few weeks and moths. Common concerns for new moms include:

Personal Comfort

Some moms feel uncomfortable with the idea of breastfeeding. There can be many reasons for this but, with proper support and education, many moms do begin to enjoy the experience of breastfeeding.

Latch on

Whilst most moms do feel some pain when initially beginning to nurse, recurrent pain can be a sign of other problems. It could simply be a matter of practicing a different technique but it can be a sign of infection.

Time and Frequency

Breastfeeding is a big commitment for new moms. Breast milk moves through your baby’s digestive system much more quickly, requiring feedings every 2-3 hours. Especially as more mothers continue to work after having children, it can be difficult to fit nursing into a busy schedule.

Diet

Components of the mothers’ diet can be passed into the breast milk and then onto the baby. Many women follow similar restrictions to their diet as during pregnancy. Fish that are higher in mercury, alcohol and caffeine intake should all be carefully monitored.

Maternal Medical Conditions

Any mothers with medical conditions or medications should always consult a doctor or lactation specialist before nursing.

All about Formula Feeding

Commercially prepared infant formulas can be a great alternative to breast milk. Formulated to contain all nutrients a growing baby needs, they can even contain some vitamins that are missing in breast milk.

If choosing to formula feed your baby, only ever buy infant formula manufactured under sterile conditions. It is not possible to create the complex combination of vitamins, proteins, fats, and sugars in formula at home.

There are many reasons that can make breastfeeding too difficult or stressful for mothers. Many moms choose to formula feed besides medical concerns.

Convenience & Flexibility

For working and busy moms, bottle feeding can be a welcome convenience. Feedings are less frequent as baby formula is digested more slowly by your baby. It is great for moms, whose partners can help with feeding duties. It is also a great way for your baby to bond with their other parent during feedings.

Formula Feeding Challenges

As with breastfeeding, there are some challenges that come with even the best infant formula.

Lack of Antibodies

Unlike breast milk, there are not natural antibodies in infant formula milk. Baby formula does provide all necessary and vital nutrition to your baby but cannot match the complexity of breast milk. Formula cannot replicate the added protection against infection that breast milk provides.

Planning and organization

Whereas breast milk is available, ready for your baby at any time, there is some additional planning with formula. Make sure that formula and the necessary supplies, like bottles, are always clean, well-stocked and accessible.

Expense

Different forms of formula come with different costs. Expenses can quickly mount up to around $1,500 for the first year of your baby’s life.

Making a Choice

Deciding how you want to feed your baby can be one of the most difficult decisions. You may not really know the answer until your baby arrives. It is not unusual to settle on one method and change your mind after your baby is born.

Whichever option you decide is best for your baby, always inform yourself on your options. If ever in doubt, talk to your doctor or lactation consultant for advice. Ultimately though, you should always make the decision which is bet for both your health and that of your baby.

All about Powdered, Ready-to-Use, and Concentrate Formulas:

There are different forms of infant formula, all of which have different benefits and drawbacks; ready-to-feed liquid, concentrated liquid and powder. Different types of formula will work better depending on your individual feeding plans and budget.

Just as you must think of time in weeks during pregnancy, bottle feeding will introduce you to ounces. Here are the basic measurements you will need for successful formula feeding:

1 ounce – 30 ml
8 fluid ounces – 1 cup
32 fluid ounces – 1 quart

Once you begin to think in ounces, you will find formula-feeding a breeze no matter which type of formula you choose. Now for the overview of the different kinds of infant formula.

Powder:

Just add powder to premeasured water and then shake to mix. Most powdered formulas eliminate any room for errors during the mixing process. You simply add 1 scoop per 2 fluid ounces of water.

Powdered formulas usually come in cans that contain enough for between 90-200 ounces of prepared infant milk.

Price

Typically, powdered formula is the least expensive option for feeding your baby. It is both economical and for most babies.

Convenience

Powdered formula is probably the easiest to prepare as you don’t need to refrigerate or heat it. You simply add it to gently warmed or room temperature water. You can choose to make it as needed. Or, plan ahead a mix up a supply for the whole day when you are making breakfast.

Digestion

As the most highly processed formula, powdered formulas can be harder for your baby to digest.

Processing

Despite this processing, there is also no guarantee that your powder is sterile.

Safety

There are slightly lower standards of FDA testing for powder than other infant formulas. There is an acceptable limit of 10,000 bacteria colonies per gram of powder. If your baby is premature or has a compromised immune system, powdered formula is not recommended.

Liquid Concentrate:

The liquid concentrate is one of the simplest options to make up. By mixing equal parts of water to concentrate, you will have a perfectly concentrated baby formula. Many parents find concentrate to be easier, neater and even more convenient than powder.

Price

The liquid concentrate is the middle band for infant formula prices. More expensive than the less convenient powder but cheaper than ready-to-feed.

Convenience

Unlike powder, refrigeration is a requirement for concentrate. You will also need to heat the formula so it is not cold for your baby. This can make traveling with concentrate formula less convenient than powder. Some parents do choose to mix an entire batch of formula in one go to be refrigerated and used over the next 48 hours.

Digestions

There is some evidence that liquid concentrate formula is more easily digested than the powdered forms.

Processing

Concentrated formula is sterilized as part of the canning process.

Safety

Though the concentrate is sterilized, your water source can introduce pathogens to the formula. Make sure you always use a safe source of water to decrease the risk of contamination.

Always clean and sterilize all equipment, including your can opener, with every use.

Ready-to-Feed:

With no mixing, measuring or mess, ready-to-feed is probably the easiest way to formula feed your baby. Typically sold in single-use containers or large cans, this formula is already the perfect concentration for your baby.

Price

The convenience of ready-to-feed infant formula makes it one of the best infant formulas for convenience. It also makes it the most expensive forms of formula. Whilst you may miss the small “ready-to-feed” label, the price will surely distinguish it from other forms. However, many mothers find that the pre-mixed formula is worth the cost because it leaves almost no room for error.

Convenience

Individual bottles of ready-to-feed formula can be served at room temperature. They are easy to keep in your baby’s diaper bag and take everywhere with you.

The cost of individual bottles can be prohibitive. A more economical option is to buy the larger containers with multiple servings. This can be refrigerated on opening and warmed before serving, much like concentrate. Unopened cans can be stored conveniently at room temperature in a cupboard or pantry.

Digestion

If your baby has digestion troubles with powder or concentrate formula, ready-to-feed could be the answer. There is some evidence that, due to easier digestion, constipation and tummy troubles are eased with ready-to-feed.

Processing

All liquid forms of infant formula are sterilized during the canning procedure. This means that there are no germs in the formula to breed in the can or bottle.

Safety

Because it is a sterile formula, ready-to-feed is one of the safest types of formula on the market. It is still important to sterilize all the bottles and nipples when feeding your baby.

How We Picked and Tested:

As a parent, you don’t just want to know which products we chose, you want to know why we chose them. So that you know that Supplemania has thoroughly reviewed every product on this list, we want to explain how we made our decisions.

Safe Ingredients

Your child’s safety is always the first concern. We have only selected formulas using ingredients that the FDA has stated are safe.

Wide research

We have read around 6000 user reviews of different products to determine what parents actually want from their infant formula. We wanted to find out what real people needed from the products.

We conducted product research on more than 21 different brands before creating our shortlist. We thoroughly analyzed the 13 products on our shortlist, all will different features and forms. We researched their websites and product guidebooks, as well as their individual reviews to determine its key features.

Volunteer Testing

Our team of volunteers all reviewed the products on our list. From this, we gained valuable real-world knowledge of how these products worked. Each volunteer gave a detailed review of their experience of feeding their baby with the product. We compared our detailed volunteer reviews with the information gained from our product research.

Our volunteers were carefully selected to ensure there was no bias in any of their reviews. Any subjective or biased reviews were not included in our final data report.

Detailed Report

All of our research is readily available to you by simply liking one of our social media pages. From that you will see the results of our extensive research and the key features behind our decisions.

Expert Opinion

Based upon all of the researched we had gathered, the Supplemania experts used their years of experience to finalize this list. We have selected the 10 best infant formula products which we will present to you in our reviews.

Advantages & Disadvantages of Breast and Formula Feeding You Should be Aware of

Most health care experts agree that breast milk is best for a newborn. There are no commercial formulas that can entirely replicate breast milk and the many advantages it has.

However, there are many reasons why breastfeeding may not be possible or desired. Some mothers choose to supplement breastfeeding with formula. The right choice is whichever is best for you and your baby.

Having said that, here are some of the things you should consider when choosing breast or formula feeding.

Newborn Health

In terms of infections and illness, breast milk does have the advantage. By passing on antibodies, mom’s breast milk is better for fighting germs. Babies who are premature often strongly benefit from breastfeeding.

Nutritionally, breastmilk is said to contain the perfect “cocktail” of baby nutrition With the perfect balance of protein, fatty acids, minerals and enzymes that a growing baby needs. However, infant formula is carefully crafted to contain a balanced and nutritious diet. It may not match breast milk entirely but it is a good option for moms who are not planning or able to breastfeed.

Mother’s Health

It is not only a baby who gets a health boost from breastmilk. Breastfeeding has been shown to reduce the risk of breast and ovarian cancers. There is also evidence that osteoporosis and hip fractures are less common in breastfeeding mothers. However, there are some potential health concerns for nursing mothers. Some moms find they are more prone to infections and fatigue during breastfeeding.

For moms who are looking to get back in shape, breastfeeding can also be advantageous. You may be surprised to learn that you could burn up to 500 calories per hour.

Allergies & Side Effects

No two babies are exactly the same. Whilst many babies experience similar problems when feeding, this is no guarantee that your baby will. Some babies have allergies that can cause unforeseen side-effects when using a product. Regardless of any stated side-effects, you should monitor your own baby when using any of these formulas. Similarly, your own baby may not experience any side-effects at all. It is all down to the individual child.

Follow Instructions:
Always follow any instructions in the product manual. There are also some common issues to be aware of. Powdered infant formulas are not sterile. They should not be fed to premature infants who may have weaker immune systems. Always consult your baby’s doctor when determining the most appropriate formula for your baby.

Always clean your equipment, boiling all bottles and nipples in water before every use. Don’t forget to sterilize all utensils used as well. To prepare formula, use water that has been boiled then cooled.

Do not use a microwave to prepare formula. It may be tempting because of the speed but can result in severe burns.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regarding dietary supplements have not been evaluated by the FDA and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or health condition.

Our Top Ten Best Infant Formula List

Finally, we have reached our review of the top ten best infant formula available on the market. We have considered 28 features of 13 different infant formulas – as you can see from our report. We have examined features such as nutrients, positive-negative reviews, and our own real-world testing. We know the actual effectiveness of each product and its features. We have also considered review frequencies to ensure the most accurate results over time. This is undoubtedly one of the most intensive studies on infant formula available in 2018.

Now I have explained the pros and cons, different kinds and positive features of infant formula. I am confident that our reviews are accurate and informative enough to provide the best overview of the best formulas.

Top Pick: Enfamil PREMIUM Infant Formula (Non-GMO)

Supplemania Score

9.7out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 85%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 3.5%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 11.5%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value
Check Price on Amazon

You are probably aware of Enfamil, one of the best-known baby formula brands. Founded almost 70 years ago, they are one of the most experienced brands around. As a mother, I always appreciate the knowledge and experience of a strong brand like Enfamil. They have tried to closely replicate the pattern of human breast milk in creating their infant milk. This premium product is one of the most nutritious formulas commercially available.

Enfamil PREMIUM Infant Formula has been created to specifically cater for babies aged up to 12 months of age. It is one of the formulas that most closely matches breast milk. This formula boasts the same amount of Omega-3, DHA and inositol as great milk. This is one of the most nourishing infant formula products.

Benefits:

First Formula

An experienced brand

Enfamil PREMIUM Infant Formula

Get It On Amazon
An experienced brand

Enfamil PREMIUM Infant Formula

This well-known brand formula, brings knowledge and experience, creating a nutritious choice that tastes good for babies and replicates the pattern of breast milk.

This formula features all of the immune boosting and brain-supporting nutrients recommended by experts. This is also packed with Vitamin D that even breast milk is lacking in.
All of the ingredients are non-GMO so you know exactly what your baby is getting.
If you are looking for a nutritious formula for your child and want a brand you know you can trust, Enfamil PREMIUM has many benefits.

Preparation:

TO MAKE* WATER POWDER
2 fl oz bottle 2 fl oz 1 unpacked level scoop (8.8 g)
4 fl oz bottle 4 fl oz 2 unpacked level scoops (17.6 g)
8 fl oz bottle 8 fl oz 4 unpacked level scoops (35.2 g)

*Each scoop adds about 0.2 fl oz to the amount of prepared formula.

Side effects

Some volunteers reported that use of this product caused gas in their babies. Other babies experienced similar digestive distress with stomach aches.

Types:

This formula comes in Powder, Concentrated Liquid and Ready-to-Feed forms. This review mainly concerns the powder form.

 best infant formula:

Why we chose this Supplement as our Top Pick?

  • We analyzed over 1000 user reviews of this product, making a note of all positive and negative features. With an impressive 7:1 positive to negative review ratio, this is clearly one of the most popular products on the market. From this we concluded that this is the product that satisfied by far the most parents and babies. Compared to other products in our shortlist, this was the runaway winner for positive reviews. We also concluded that some of the positive reviews are also based upon the excellent value for money in terms of price and effectiveness.
  • Our own Supplemania scoring system gave Enfamil Premium a score of 9.7. The review frequency is also incredible, with its first ten reviews coming in in a mere 16 days. This frequency continued, with its second and third ten reviews coming in just 20 and 13 days respectively. This is a popular product that people feel very strongly about. Its popularity is long lasting and many parents recommend this product in their reviews.
  • The price falls in the average range compared to other products on the market. It comes in at around $26 for a single pack. A pack of six actually costs more per pack. We recommend economizing by buying multiple single packs.
  • This was widely reported as a product that babies enjoyed the taste of. Most parents found their babies were well fed and enjoyed this formula. The powder is easy to mix, making preparation simple. There were also no reports from our volunteers of constipation in their child.

Organic Pick: Earth’s Best Organic Infant Formula Powder

Supplemania Score

9.2out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 68.2%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 8.2%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 23.6%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value

If you are looking for the best organic infant formula, the Hain Celestial Group are one of the go-to brands. They recognize the importance of wholesome nourishment, free from any nasty chemicals. Their commitment is to safe and gentle products for your baby. They only use pure ingredients, found in nature.

Earth’s Best Organic Infant Formula is made using only organic milk. All of the cows that produce their milk are fed organic feeds, hay and grain, with no synthetic fertilizers and pesticides.

Organic option

Second place pick

Earth’s Best Organic Infant Formula Powder

Get It On Amazon
Second place pick

Earth’s Best Organic Infant Formula Powder

If you are looking for something organic, then this could be a good choice. It uses pure and natural ingredients to make a product that is healthy and nutritious for your little one.

Their commitment to simple ingredients means no added corn syrup. It is fortified only with nourishing vitamins and minerals such as DHA and ARA. These added fatty acids are found in breast milk and support both brain and eye health in your baby. Immunity is also boosted by prebiotic fiber making it a good alternative to breast milk.

Why we Chose This as Our Organic Pick?

This product actually has the highest number of reviews on our list. At the time of our research, this product had a staggering 1045 reviews. Having considered both positive and negative reviews, we found it achieved a Supplemania score of 9.2. This is one of the best scores we gave to any product on our list. The positive reviews are much higher in number than the negative, with a ratio of 3:1, showing the great popularity of this organic infant formula.

This popularity can be seen in the rating of reviews, receiving its first, second and third 10 ratings in just 26, 34 and 20 days respectively.

Compared to other organic infant formulas, this is the highest rated for cost. The product comes in at just $24 for 23.2 ounces of formula. The price is also below average, making it one of the best value infant formulas.

I found the option of choosing between milk or soy plant-based formulas was a real boost to this product. If your baby suffers from lactose intolerance, the sensitive formula can really ease constipation and gas. The formula is easy to digest and will fit in with most dietary requirements.

 best infant formula:

Benefits:

This product is designed to closely match breast milk. It contains many proteins and minerals found in breast milk, making this a good choice for an organic breast milk alternative.

The added DHA & ARA will strongly support mental and visual development and the immune system will be supported with prebiotic fiber. All around, this is one of the best infant formulas for anyone looking for a good value, organic product.

Preparation:

TO MAKE* WATER POWDER
2-oz bottle 2 fl oz 1 unpacked level scoop (8.7g)
4-oz bottle 4 fl oz 2 unpacked level scoops (17.4g)
6-oz bottle 6 fl oz 3 unpacked level scoops (26.1 g)
8-oz bottle 8 fl oz. 4 unpacked level scoops (34.8g)

Side effects

Some digestive issues reported include gas and constipation. Some spit up was also noted by volunteers.

Types:

This product comes in a wide variety of powder forms; Organic Dairy, Organic Sensitivity, Organic Gentle Infant Formula with Iron, Non-GMO Soy Plant, Organic Dairy Non-DHABased

Value Pick: Similac Advance Infant Formula

Supplemania Score

9.5out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 87.2%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 7.6%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 5.2%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value
Check Price on Amazon

Why We Chose This as Our Value Pick?

Similac – the nutrition brand of global healthcare company Abbot – makes this nutritional, milk based formula. With both milk and soy-based formulas, they are also iron-fortified for healthy development. The OptiGRO™ blend, containing DHA, lutein and vitamin E, provides many nu-trients found in breast milk.

Value formula

Save money choice

Similac Advance Infant Formula

Get It On Amazon
Save money choice

Similac Advance Infant Formula

If you want a great value and economical option, then this product from Similac comes as a three pack. With all the added expenses of being a parent, this pack could save you some money.

The reviews of this product are overwhelmingly positive. An incredible 34:1 ratio of positive to negative reviews over 400 reviews shows that almost all users liked this formula. This is a good product for anyone looking for a recommendation from other parents. Almost all of the 400 parents who used and reviewed this formula would recommend it to others.

The review frequency of this product is very strong and there are plenty of up to date reviews to read. The first, second and third 10 reviews came in in just 38, 35 and 37 days, respectively. The average user rating of 4.5 is part of the reasoning behind our Supplemania score – 9.5.

 best infant formula:

This product was not quite getting the review frequency of our top pick. Because of that, we have to assume it is selling slightly less. We could not quite give it our top pick but it certainly is the best Value Pick.

This is the most economical product compared to other infant formulas. With the great value pack of three, you can get 108 ounces for $97. This is a great amount of feedings for the price. This product has the highest value score of 5. This is equal to its price index and effectiveness score so you know you are getting a high-value product.

Parenting can be expensive and I always love to find a great product that is also a bargain price. It gives me little bits of extra money to treat my baby and myself.

Benefits:

DHA, one of the fatty acids in breast milk, aids healthy eye and brain development. Lutein further supports eye health, giving your baby’s eyesight a nice headstart. Plenty of vitamin E supports your baby’s developing cells.

Preparation:

TO MAKE* WATER POWDER
2-oz bottle 2 fl oz 1 unpacked level scoop (8.7g)
4-oz bottle 4 fl oz 2 unpacked level scoops (17.4g)
6-oz bottle 6 fl oz 3 unpacked level scoops (26.1 g)
8-oz bottle 8 fl oz. 4 unpacked level scoops (34.8g)

Side effects

Some babies are not keen on this formula with most negative reviews reporting fussiness. As with many formulas, there were some instances of gas.

Types:

Coming in Powder and Ready-to-Feed forms, this is a convenient formula for both at home and away.

A List of 7 Other Products We Reviewed

No 4: Enfamil Nutramigen Infant Formula

Supplemania Score

9.1out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 79.3%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 6.5%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 14.2%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value

Another Enfamil entry on our list, this is a formula for children with allergies. More common than you may think, lactose intolerance can cause a lot of discomfort for your baby. This hypoallergenic and lactose-free formula is highly recommended for many sensitive babies.

Again, Enfamil is a strong brand with a reputation to trust. For parents, this experience will be highly appreciated. This is a formula that has been developed as a hypoallergenic formula with all of the same excellent features as the regular infant formulas by Enfamil.

Recommended pick

Non-lactose lifesaver

Enfamil Nutramigen Infant Formula

Get It On Amazon
Non-lactose lifesaver

Enfamil Nutramigen Infant Formula

This formula is a safe bet for parents who have lactose intolerant babies. Although some parents say the flavor wasn’t great, it is a convenient choice.

Many parents describe this product as a “lifesaver” for their lactose-intolerant children. For any babies who cannot drink nonfat milk, this product mixes with water so avoids upset tummies.
Some babies were not keen on the tase, but most got used to the formula after a few feedings. This is also a comment that we have heard from other hypoallergenic formula users. The change in diet could also trigger some digestive issues but, in many cases, will fix any digestive issues caused by allergies.

 best infant formula:

Gentle Formula
Even babies who struggle to keep other formulas down have shown much success with this formula. Some parents did report some digestive issues but most found that their babies had improved digestion.

Price
The complex formula makes this one of the more expensive products on our list. This was the source of some of the more negative reviews. This is actually a very well reviewed product. Most parents feel this formula is worth the price because its formula works very well for their child.

Benefits:

Highly supportive of the immune system.

Great for allergy management, the hypoallergenic formula should ease feeding for children with allergies and intolerance.

Supportive of the digestive system. The formula is designed to be gentle on tummies.

Price:

Approx. $142 for a 4 pack (19.8 ounces)

Preparation:

TO MAKE* WATER POWDER
2 fl oz bottle 2 fl oz 1 packed level scoop (9 g)
4-oz bottle 4 fl oz 2 unpacked level scoops (8 g)
8-oz bottle 8 fl oz. 4 unpacked level scoops (36 g)

Side effects

Despite the hypoallergenic formula, there were some reported cases of gas and spit up. Even the most hypoallergenic formula could still cause reactions in some babies.

Types:

Available in all forms, powder, concentrated liquid, and ready-to-feed, you can use it in the most convenient form for yourself.

No 5: Enfamil PREMIUM Newborn Formula

Supplemania Score

9.3out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 77.5%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 6.1%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 16.4%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value
Check Price on Amazon

Similar to our top pick, this is the Non-GMO version of Enfamil’s Premium infant formula. With certified and traceable ingredients, it is good to know that your baby is getting an all natural diet. Some parents believed that this was a closer formula to breast milk because of its natural ingredients.

Again, this is a premium product. It includes all of the nutrients your baby needs only no GMO products. The results are not entirely the same, hence the lower spot on our list. Still if non-GMO is important to you, this product is the closest match to our top pick.

Premium pick

A popular choice

Enfamil PREMIUM Newborn Formula

Get It On Amazon
A popular choice

Enfamil PREMIUM Newborn Formula

This formula has some good reviews from Moms, as it is quite a premium formula, packed full of goodness, yet it still comes in at a good value price and isn’t crazily expensive.

For anyone confused about what non-GMO actually means, it is simply that no gene-splicing has been used in any ingredients of this product. Many health organizations believe that there are no risks involved with GMO ingredients, but for most parents, the safety of your child is not worth the risk. Enfamil have very strict standards for suppliers to ensure that all ingredients are non-GMO.

Popularity
In reviews, some mothers described this formula as better than other formulas they had used in the past. Despite some minor digestion issues, there were few reported side-effects from our volunteers.

Value
Overall, this product has one of the lower effectiveness ratings but its price does give it a big boost for value. If you are looking for a supplementary formula that does not break the bank, you could do worse than this product.
 best infant formula:

Digestion
Gas was the main reported side-effect. Some babies experienced wind, so it may not be the best for very sensitive tummies. Other parents found that their baby digested this infant milk much better than other brands. This is mostly down to each individual baby’s tolerance.

Benefits:

Containing all of the recommended Vitamin D, this is a well-supplemented formula.

All ingredients are certified non-GMO. Lots of parents will be pleased that Enfamil offers their popular product in a non-GMO version.

The focus is on fostering a healthy immune system, just as breast milk does.

Price:

22.2 ounce costs around $26. This is one of the better value products on our list.

Preparation:

TO MAKE* WATER POWDER
2 fl oz bottle 2 fl oz 1 packed level scoop (9 g)
4-oz bottle 4 fl oz 2 unpacked level scoops (8 g)
8-oz bottle 8 fl oz. 4 unpacked level scoops (36 g)

Side effects

Some gas and wind.

Types:

This product is available, like our top pick, in Powder and Ready-to-Feed forms.

No 6: Plum Organics “Grow Well” Organic Infant Formula

Supplemania Score

8.4out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 71%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 9%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 20%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value

The first entry for Plum Organics on our list, this is another one for parents looking for organic infant formulas. This formula comes in two different versions. Premium is designed to closely replicate breast milk and Gentle is good for sensitive tummies.

Plum Organics actually started as an organic food company. They have years of experience selling quality foods and hold their baby formula to the same standards. With no nasty additives and unhealthy corn syrup makes it into this formula.

This product is designed as a premium product. There are only good, healthy ingredients included in this formula. As a mother, I love Plum Organics’ strong focus on ingredients that are good for my child, not for their budgets.

Quality product

A high-end choice

Plum Organics “Grow Well” Organic Infant Formula

Get It On Amazon
A high-end choice

Plum Organics “Grow Well” Organic Infant Formula

This formula comes in a couple of formulations, always being organic. The ingredients are natural, and for that you have to pay a little bit of a higher price.

However, this focus on premium products does make for a slightly above average price. This is something you need to weigh up when considering using this formula for your baby. If you do decide that organic, nonfat milk formula is best for your child, Grow Well is a very strong choice.

Dietary
This formula is kosher as well as dairy any lactose-free. This is a formula that will be suitable for all diets. The Gentle version is particularly easy on your baby’s digestive system.

Reviews
 best infant formula:
This product has not got the greatest review rating or frequency. It is popular amongst many parents but some found the price off-putting. Others liked the no-nonsense ingredients and felt it was worth the money. Overall, this does fall lower on our list because of its slightly lower popularity.

Benefits:

This milk is complex, inspired by natural breast milk, it is designed to support growth and development in your baby.

I always want to know that my baby is only getting the best ingredients. All of the traceable and healthy ingredients of this formula really put my mind at ease when I think about what my baby is eating.

The two different versions give you a choice, depending on your own baby’s dietary needs.

Price:

At $42 per 32 ounce package, this is not the best value product on our list.

Preparation:

TO MAKE* WATER POWDER
2-oz bottle 2 fl oz 1 unpacked level scoop (8.5g)
4-oz bottle 4 fl oz 2 unpacked level scoops (17g)
6-oz bottle 6 fl oz 3 unpacked level scoops (25.5g)
8-oz bottle 8 fl oz. 4 unpacked level scoops (34g)

Side effects

Some digestive issues, particularly with the Premium version. Constipation and gas were reported in more than one case.

Types:

This formula only comes in powder form. As such, it is not suitable for premature babies who need sterilized formula.

No 7: Similac Pro-Advance Non-GMO Infant Formula

Supplemania Score

8.8out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 76%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 4.5%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 19.5%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value
Check Price on Amazon

Similac make another appearance in our top ten list. This is no surprise as one of America’s most popular baby formula brands. The non-GMO formula of Similac, this formula is popular amongst fans of the Similac brand with non-GMO diets.

Nutrition
Of the many positive reviews, most were about how well-nourished parents felt their babies were on this formula. It is always wonderful to feel your baby is thriving and this formula does seem to work really well for many children.

Popularity

Average option

For formula fans

Similac Pro-Advance Non-GMO Infant Formula

Get It On Amazon
For formula fans

Similac Pro-Advance Non-GMO Infant Formula

Although this formula does claim a lot of fans, as it is one of the biggest brand names, it also has some downsides, with some Moms saying their babies still didn’t like this formula.

However, this is a product that has also received its fair share of negative reviews. Upset stomach was the most frequent cause of lower reviews. It has not quite reached the higher levels of our list because of this.

Digestion
Despite some instances of upset stomach, other parents found that their baby’s stool resembled that of breastfed stool. They believed that this formula actually aided their child’s digestion. It is possible that this is just not a product that is good for sensitive digestive systems.

Benefits:

This is generally a good value product, offering a lot of benefits for an average price.

This product was considered close to breastmilk by many parents. Most reviews were divided on whether is supported digestion or upset stomachs.

The nutritional value is very high, with lots of healthy babies being fed on this formula.

Price:

 best infant formula:
23 ounce costs around $27. This is a good value product for its effectiveness rating, as you can see from our open report.

Side effects

Reported upset stomach in some babies.

Types:

This formula only comes in powder form. Anyone wanting the convenience of ready-to-feed should look at other entries on the list.

No 8: Enfamil Enspire Infant Formula

Supplemania Score

8.5out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 77.6%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 7.5%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 14.9%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value
Check Price on Amazon

This is the final Enfamil product on our list. Enfamil’s appearances on this list show that they are a brand with an impressive and effective output. This is their version of the formula that is touted as “the closest to breast milk” which is certainly a bold claim.

Review Frequency
This is one of the less reviewed products on the list. It does not have the popularity of other Enfamil products we reviewed.

Price

Not our favourite

A high price tag

Enfamil Enspire Infant Formula

Get It On Amazon
A high price tag

Enfamil Enspire Infant Formula

This formula is another product from Enfamil, but it is less popular. It costs a lot of money, yet is pretty limited as it only comes as a powder. Maybe choose another higher ranked Enfamil formula for a better product.

It is also one of the more expensive products you will see in our report. This is really marketed as a premium formula and it has a price tag to match. Despite this, it only comes in powder forms so your choice is fairly limited. Some reviewers found it was selling at nearly double the price of our top pick, Enfamil Premium. Many would argue that our Top Pick represents a better value choice.

Side-Effects
This is not necessarily a formula focused on digestion. Primarily supporting immune systems and cognitive development, it is not always easy on stomachs. Some babies experience digestive issues when feeding on this formula.

 best infant formula:

Benefits:

An MFGM enriched formula, this is a product designed to support and encourage cognitive development.

Lactoferrin helps to boost the immune system in a way that is supposed to imitate the immune support of breast milk.

This is one of the most complete formulas for nutrition, however, the ingredients do cause a higher than average rate of upset tummies.

Price:

20.5 ounce cost around $57

Preparation:

TO MAKE* WATER POWDER
2 fl oz bottle 2 fl oz 1 scoop (8.8 g)
4-oz bottle 4 fl oz 2 scoops (17.6 g)
8-oz bottle 8 fl oz. 4 scoops (35.2 g)

Side effects

Gas and bloating was reported in a slightly higher number of reviewers than average. The complex formula contains many ingredients, possibly increasing its chances to contain allergens.

Types:

This formula is available only in powder form.

No 9: Similac For Supplementation Non-GMO Infant Formula

Supplemania Score

8.2out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 82.2%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 6.5%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 11.3%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value
Check Price on Amazon

This is another Similac product but it is also the first product on our list to be designed specifically for supplementing breastfeeding. If you like to breastfeed your baby when possible but also use formula for convenience, this is a product designed for you.

Not every mother can breastfeed all of the time. Many partners would like to have a more active role in the feeding process. This formula, which complements rather than replaces breastfeeding, allows anyone to be a part of your baby’s healthy diet.

This nonfat milk formula is also a great help for anyone wanting to move from breastfeeding to formula feeding. By supplementing your baby’s diet alongside breastfeeding, this transition should be easier on the tummy and body.

In addition, Similac’s own OptiGRO blend of nutrients will help to keep your baby growing healthily and strongly. Plus, the extra iron will also help to combat anemia.

Designed as a Supplement

Super supplement

A convenient choice

Similac For Supplementation Non-GMO Infant Formula

Get It On Amazon
A convenient choice

Similac For Supplementation Non-GMO Infant Formula

This formula is a supplement to breastfeeding. You can use it as a timesaver and a convenient option to aid your baby’s diet. Not only will it give some of the night feeds to your partner, it will keep your baby well-nourished too.

With its ingredients formulated to supplement rather than replace breast milk, it has a slightly different makeup than other formulas on our list. It features added vitamins not found in breast milk. It also has lower concentrations of some nutrients found in breast milk.

Convenience & Affordability

BY using this formula as a supplement to free breastfeeding, this can really help to keep the costs down. Your partner can help with those pesky night feeds using the formula. Both parents you can both have special bonding time with your baby without having to entirely give up the benefits of breast milk.

If you find that you have a lower supply of milk, this can allow you to breastfeed whilst ensuring your baby is well nourished.

Added support for your baby

Because it is created as a supplement, there is a strong focus on nutrients that support growth and development. Because of the immune boosting and digestive benefits of breast milk, this formula is free to concentrate on other areas, such as growth, with more precision.

 best infant formula:

Benefits:

Developing cells are supported by a rich OptiGRO formula. The ideal supplement for breastfeeding moms.

Great value for money, partly because the cost is offset by natural breast milk.

This is not the best recipe for exclusive formula feeding. Instead, it supplements all of the vital minerals and vitamins missing from breast milk.

Price:

92.8 ounce comes in at an average of $111. Great value because this goes a long way thanks to the addition of breastfeeding.

Side effects

Lactose can cause constipation and spit-up in intolerant babies. However, some side-effects are offset by the benefits of breast milk for many babies.

Types:

Available is powder and ready-to-feed, it can stay at home or be slipped into your purse for days out.

No 10: Similac NeoSure for Premature Babies Formula

Supplemania Score

8.3out of 10
Percentage of Positive Reviews: 88%
Percentage of Neutral Reviews: 4.5%
Percentage of Negative Reviews: 7.5%
User Ratings
Effectiveness
Value

The final Similac and final entry on our list, this is actually one of the most positively reviewed products we analyzed. Similac are a strong brand with many popular products. However, slightly lower reviews than average meant that we did not have such a thorough overview of this product as other entries.

The added iron in this formula is a real boost, particularly for premature babies. Many babies suffer from anemia, which can be quite alarming for parents. However, a boost in iron should help to sort out this common problem.

Similac are a popular brand, one that you know you can trust. As a parent, I have always appreciated a strong brand with an expert product.

Positive pick

One for premature babies

Similac NeoSure for Premature Babies Formula

Get It On Amazon
One for premature babies

Similac NeoSure for Premature Babies Formula

This formula is good value for money, and is designed with premature babies in mind. It is packed full of extra iron, which will help give an early baby a great start.

Here, Similac have applied their expertise to a formula designed for premature babies. Many premature babies are already more vulnerable to many problems. Difficulty gaining weight and lower immune systems are all common. This formula aims to boost all areas that are problematic for premature babies.

Popularity

Because this product is less reviewed than others, we much conclude it is less popular at this time. However, the reviews it has received are 11;1 positive to negative, an impressive ratio. Though this formula is not widely known, it is well-liked.

Nutrition

This product is right in nutrition, with a focus on weight gain. Head circumference and length are also a focus of this formula. The ready-to-feed, sterile formula, is a good source of weight gain for small, premature babies.

Value
Good value for money, the price is reasonable and it is one of the cheapest formulas for such a positive number of features.

 best infant formula:

Benefits:

Specifically designed to support growth in babies up to 12 months. This is a very supportive formula for development in your baby’s first year.

Good value, this product is both popular and well priced. A bonus for anyone looking for a great deal.

Good reviews, though infrequent, show that this product is popular when used. Many parents would recommend this formula to friends and family.

Price:

A $110 for 78.6 ounces, this is above-average in terms of value. The price is good in comparison to other products we have featured.

Side effects

As with many formulas, there were reported digestive issues. Constipation and spit up being the most common complaints.

Types:

Available in powder and ready-to-feed, this is a versatile product.

A List of Other Products We Tested

Glossary

Protein
Complex chains of amino acids that build and repair tissue in the body.

Linoleic Acid
An essential fatty acid found in breast milk.

Vitamins: A, C, D, E, K, thiamin (B1), riboflavin (B2), B6, B12
Vitamins are essential in order for the body to function properly. Adults find them in our diets and babies need them in their diets as well.

Niacin
A good amount of niacin in a diet helps to prevent cardiovascular disease.

Folic Acid
One of the key nutrients taken by pregnant women, folic acid helps the healthy development of your child.

Pantothenic Acid
One of the key acids that allows the stabilization of carbohydrates and fats in the diet.

Calcium
Helps to build strong and healthy bones.

Minerals: Magnesium, Iron, Zinc, Copper, Manganese
These minerals are considered essential because your body uses them for various functions. Usually found as part of a healthy diet, they can also be supplemented

Phosphorus
Phosphorus helps kidneys work well and prevents kidney disease.

Iodine
The body uses iodine to create hormones but it has no way of producing iodine, so it must be part of a diet or supplement.

Nucleotides
Involved in metabolic processes, they are essential for the body to work. Compared to human breast milk, cow’s milk has lower levels of nucleotides so many companies add it to their infant formula.

Wrapping it Up

Is it normal for my baby to spit up after feedings?

Most babies will experience some spit-up after feedings. It could be a sign that they have eaten too much or just some digestive troubles. Make sure you feed your baby upright and burp after feedings.

Some babies will experience spit-up because of an allergy. Try hypoallergenic formulas if your baby is allergic or intolerant to breast milk or other formulas.

Can I breastfeed when I am sick?

In most cases, yes. Your body produces antibodies during an illness which are passed on through breast milk to your child.

However, if you have a medical condition such as HIV, this can be passed on during feeding. If this is the case, finding a good formula should keep your baby healthy.

My baby bites during breastfeeding. How can I prevent this?

When babies begin teething, it is quite common for them to bite at the end of nursing. Quickly pop a finger in the corner of your baby’s mouth to break the suction. Also, reward your baby every time they do not bite with plenty of kisses and cuddles.

Does My breastfed baby need supplemental vitamins?

Generally, breast milk provides all the nutrients your baby needs. However, some vitamins (such as Vitamin D) are not present in breast milk and will need to be supplemented.

Infant formulas are created with all essential nutrients and vitamins so there should be no need for extra supplementation.